For those who read my BLArticles® you probably know that I have a passion for helping those in career transition. I try to help them find work. It can be one of the most lifechanging gifts you can offer another human being. Being on the frontline of providing this kind of support, I’ve seen my share of resumes. According to a study released this week by TheLadders, an online job-matching service, recruiters spend an average of six to seven seconds looking at a resume. When I’m handed a resume, I clock in even faster than that, and that’s because I can find out all I need to know without reading one word.
I’m sure I sound callous when I make that kind of a statement, but I want to clarify the point I’m trying to make: I didn’t say I wasn’t looking at the resume. I said I wasn’t reading the words. I suppose I could take a minute or two looking for a typo, but I’m not all that interested in, nor do I put that much stock in, finding typos. I know that others might look for the typos, but not me. That’s probably because I was taught quite a lesson by a typo once. I feel a story coming on: cue the dream sequence music…
Once upon a time, I had a typo in a resume that I had looked over countless times. I had been working on it for weeks. That typo wasn’t there because I was too lazy to find it, and it wasn’t there due to a lack of caring about it. My mind kept reading the word “form” as “from,” and that one word made all of the difference in the next interview I was going to.
It was a training specialist job for a major Fortune 500 company. The interview consisted of a 60-minute panel interview, followed by a 20-minute live delivery. I nailed the interview, and when it came to the live delivery, I nailed that too. When was the last time you saw someone come into your conference room carrying his own, folding, portable lectern?! I had that room at, “I hope you don’t mind that I brought my own lectern. You can never be too sure if there’s one waiting for you.”
When I finished, I knew I had that room in the palm of my hand… or at least I thought I did. As each panelist shook my hand on his or her way out, each was smiling and complementing me on the job I had just done. The hiring manager stayed behind. When the room cleared, he gave me the bad news. “You know there isn’t a person on that panel who isn’t ready to hire you right now, and no one has even come close to delivering the kind of presentation you just delivered. That said, you have a typo in your resume and for that reason, and that reason alone, I will not hire you.”
I walked out with my tail between my legs, discouraged and disappointed with myself. It turned out the word, “form” cost me a job I really wanted. As I look back on that interview now, I happen to think the word, “form,” also cost that company a world-class professional speaker who was rising within his field… but I digress.
I refuse to judge the character of someone I’m looking to evaluate based on a typo. To me, although a typo is no welcome guest on any document, it’s not a reflection of character. When I look at someone’s resume, I’m not looking for typing errors; I’m looking for formatting errors. To be clear, formatting errors relate to appearance or layout, such as when columns don’t line up, or bullets are mismatched, or there is a lack of consistency in titles, and so on.
There’s a big difference between a typo and formatting errors. I don’t know anyone who is aware of a typo and willingly ignores it. I know how a typo can be almost impossible to find. But formatting errors speak volumes to me because they are almost impossible to miss, and they seem to be symptomatic of laziness and a lack of interest in correcting them. What’s more, I think it’s important to note that a formatting issue is not just limited to resumes. There are many examples of formatting issues in how we conduct ourselves:
- When I see someone communicating virtually with a cluttered and distracting background, I have to assume the individual knows what it looks like but thinks, “it’s clean enough.”I’m left wondering just how much pride and care this person places on the work he or she performs.
- When I see a for-sale sign in a yard that’s crooked, I have to assume the realtor knows what it looks like but thinks, “it’s straight enough.” I’m left wondering just how much attention to detail I can expect from this realtor. After all, I am looking for someone to help me navigate one of the most important and complicated decisions I’ll ever make.
- When I see someone show up two minutes late for either a live meeting or a virtual one, I have to assume the individual had a few others things he or she needed to do and feels, “I’m not that late.”I’m left wondering just how dependable I can expect this person to be moving forward.
Formatting to me can come in many shapes and sizes, but at the end of the day, it reflects a critical trait that is highly desired, and difficult to spot. That trait is “hustle.” When was the last time you worked with someone who showed an innate ability to hustle, and then he or she later disappointed you? You know, I can’t think of one either.
Looking forward to putting out another podcast soon! For now, if you haven’t been there yet, check out “Pocket Sized Pep Talks.” My latest podcast, Handling Those Negative Voices, might be just what you need during these times of uncertainty. Now’s not the time to let these negative voices have their way; we’ve got this! Please listen – follow – rate – review! https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/pocket-sized-pep-talks/id1497772972
You might want to also listen to some of the others there including a short piece I did on “Worry.” If you’re struggling, have a listen, and I think you’ll learn a few tricks that will assist you, and you’ll feel a little better as well!
- I’ve appeared on the “Small Business Advocate Show” with Jim Blasingame for almost 20 years now, and you’ll find dozens of our conversations on his website. We just sat down last week for a great conversation on setting up your home virtual studio, and staying productive during the current crisis. Here’s a link to over 100 interviews done over the years, including my most recent that explores the myths and techniques involved in closing. https://www.smallbusinessadvocate.com/small-business-experts/rob-jolles-134
- I was recently interviewed on the “Salesman Podcast,” which was a lot of fun. If you’re looking to Change Minds, check out this podcast: https://www.salesman.org/the-simple-step-by-step-process-to-influence-anyone-with-rob-jolles/
- I loved talking about the book, Why People Don’t Believe You on a podcast that I’m sure you’ll like called Onward Nation: https://predictiveroi.com/podcasts/rob-jolles/
- After 30+ years as a professional speaker and trainer, one of the most common questions I get is this: “How do we make sure the training sticks?” Take a moment and listen to this podcast; “SalesChats” with John Golden. If you want to know why most training fails, listen up! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KR3dDOlTK7U&list=FLxBXKhqz0xBwbUPMqNthAJA&index=2&t=1293s
Terrific post Rob. I’m sure the guy who rejected you regretted that decision. You went on to become a Rock Star Trainer/Speaker/Author.
All the Best my friend,
Neil
Wow, I sure appreciate that Neil, and coming from a guy like you who is a top tier professional speaker, I’m grateful. I did meet that guy years later. He remembered interviewing me, but couldn’t remember why he didn’t hire me. I reminded him, and then I signed his book. 🙂
I’m one of those people who won’t hire someone for a typo or formatting, but misspellings get me more than something like form vs. from. My feeling is that it is a bad sign if someone can’t get the resume perfect. Now complement vs. compliment is a different story! 😉
Stay safe!
Dan
I knew I was going to hear from Team Typo on this one!! 🙂 It’s not a perfect science. How are you on “they” versus “him or her”? I struggle with this one mightily. We might both be right if we consider what we’re hiring for. Glad you posted Dan – I needed that other side of this issue!
As always, a great and thoughtful article. Even specialized grammatical software can miss a typo. I read many documents backward in an effort to ensure I did not miss a typo. I have also changed the software to avoid layout problems.
Thanks again for your great insight.
I’ve heard reading documents backwards is a great move. While at Xerox I used to perform a small exercise that had people look at a card and count how many “f’s” were on the card. There was no way to do it successfully unless you read it backwards and didn’t actually read the words! It was a great exercise with a handful of lessons attached to it! Thanks so much for posting Phyllis!
A great read with profound perspectives on often ignored issue. Thanks, Rob. I like how you extrapolate from the formatting of documents to how we conduct ourselves. Yes, formatting you addressed reflects a trait. It also conveys a discipline.
I was hoping people would stay with the BLArticle® and realize I wasn’t just focusing on formatting a document. I think it goes far deeper than that and I’m glad you got it! Thank you for posting Hui!
Thank you for persuading me to become a little more forgiving on typos. Excellent lesson.
I do agree on the formatting concept – and also in its broadest sense. Totally on-point.
Indeed, I go perhaps one further than you on the formatting. Particularly if I’m hiring someone for a position that involves a lot of writing, I’ll look at their resume if it is sent in a .doc format rather than PDF to see how they formatted it. Do they use tab stops correctly or do they use multiple spaces, for example. Or, for plus points, have they formatted manually or using styles.
If I gave you a nudge to be a little more forgiving of typos, I did my job! I’m surprised people would send a resume in a word doc because sometimes formatting shifts a bit based on different Word programs. Here the Jolles-Formatting system might fail me because I could see a rather obvious formatting issue on my end that might not be there on the other person’s screen. Not to self: If you want to make sure you’re formatting is clean, (and that David isn’t inspecting your formatting,) send a PDF! 🙂 Thanks for posting David.
Great blog, Rob. I have never consciously looked at resumes from this perspective. Until now, spelling mistakes were always a total no-go for me in job applications. But I completely agree with you: spelling mistakes and formatting errors have a completely different significance!
Welcome to the club Patrick! It’s not a perfect science, but I believe one is far worse than the other. Thanks for posting.
This was interesting to me, because I have a hard time formatting documents due to issues and figuring out software. And if you don’t do a PDF, you never know how the formatting will come to the person who gets the e-mail. Some of us don’t use PDF’s due to disability access issues. But I will work on it, now that at least one person has told me formatting is more important than typos!
Well, this one person should be listened to! You are absolutely right – a Word doc on my computer may format completely different on your computer. PDF’s have always made me feel confident what I’m seeing, others are seeing. But if there’s a disability access issue, then we do the best we can do! Thanks for posting Dale.